Jellyfin client side transcoding reddit. • 2 yr. Clear the browser cache, go to the URL in the browser and load only the first part of the local address until the first slash, and try loading it again. 6 I noticed that whenever I play something on my android devices, jellyfin launches ffmpeg with -codec:v:0 libx264 instead of -codec:v:0 copy even though the source material is also H. I personally recommend VLC as it's highly compatible with many different encoding methods. 8. I am new to this. Under the video tab, I set the framerate to 'same as source' and the video codec to h264. Useful_Age3518. 12. , if you have x265 content, and your client player can only decode x264, you'll need to transcode). Then I went in to jellyfins settings, activated hardware acceleration, put it to nvidia nvenc, I checked all the boxes under it (including hardware decoding I have Jellyfin 10. The remember position in a video is specially server side because it is streaming and so you can pick up at the same point on any other client. My problem is, I can't seem to get HEVC decoding to work, and that's a problem since that's what most of my library is. Open the MKV file in Handbrake. I'm really at a lost here. x stable. You own all your data, and it never gets held or controlled by anyone else's servers in the cloud. But is missing some big Plex features. Hardware accelerated HDR to H. Fix video download option to open links in browser. For example, my Jellyfin VM accesses the NAS via a NFS mount in the underlying OS (Ubuntu 20. It requires so much processing and lowers video quality. Update your stack. Most of my clients direct play my files and if some video transcoding is needed I have an Nvidia card to make it effortless to my system running Plex. All you need to set is the " (Optional) Shared network folder:" option for your media. In the future get something like a 2200G or 3200G - lower power and cheap. They offer more playback support than browsers do As long as your network is fast enough, and your client supports the encoded formats, jellyfin will avoid transcoding the file by default. Not the most elegant solution as the playback experience isn't as native, however MPV can play pretty much everything and requires no setup. The client is roku and they have not added quality options in the player yet so I’m curious if I can force that client to transcode server side. Plex is the more mature of the two and has extra features like skip intro, skip credits, transcode+download and way more client support. Better outside for performance reasons, so we can avoid transcoding. Select the general fast 720p preset. It will sometimes keep showing the Emby menu. Switch to NativeShell interface for jellyfin-web extensions. Please visit us at our new forums. In dashboard->users->username you can set a bitrate limit and then everything over that limit will be transcoded down to it. It’s the duty of client to request Jellyfin Mobile for iOS 1. I've spent a great deal of time software-transcoding all of my media into HEVC at very slow speed and don't want the video to take a huge quality hit as a result of hardware transcoding on-the-fly for the sake of PGS subtitles. 3. 04 in my case). I set and enabled hardware acceleration in playback transcoding on server. 7. 264/H. Simply select video, audio and subtitle formats you know your clients support, then use any ol' video converter to turn all your media to that format. No Desktop environment, just ssh from my windows PC. 2. Either the client can play it or it can't and if it can't then the server transcodes it to something the client can play. yml up -d. It always ends up transcoding. 264/AVC. If you can spend a bit more, the GTX 1060. If you don’t have a suitable hardware decoder, the media will still be software transcoded. HWA auto detection is not finished yet. One will say "Jellyfin Server", and the other is just "jellyfin". So the video doesn't transcode and plays like normal - this is fine for videos with lower bitrates, but for videos with higher bitrates it buffers too much to be watchable. It's a huge deal when considering the benefit to privacy that SelfHosting is best for. Truenas doesn't support Arc yet. Coincidentally, my 2400G is faster at encoding than a dedicated GPU because it has newer and more capable silicon. I have been running a jellyfin server off of my Raspberry Pi 4 4gb for about a week now streaming to my Roku TV. I reccomend you try out kodi or mpv shim to play files from your jellyfin server. If jellyfin is transcoding, it's because the client does not, in fact, support the encoding for one reason or another. It's getting to a point where I don't even know why I am keeping Kodi in the mix. Web and desktop player work flawlessly on my Linux desktop, some videos freeze the windows desktop player. I get this error; This client isn't compatible with the media and the server isn't sending a compatible media format. ffmpeg does not magically increase quality. 0 (no boosting). With now devices with AV1 support coming out in masse, at least the majority of devices should be already supporting HEVC. (One can only hardly determine the resulting Bitrate from the quality setting. I understand the reasoning why - internet speeds, unsupported video files on devices. For my external users I share with plex only. Here is my setup: HDHomeRun Flex 4K. I used the RX580 before (99% same as your RX480) and it was pretty good at encoding (I use OpenShot at work). That's the whole point. The point is to have a server that will take care of metadata, watch status, transcode, etc. My rig has 2x E5-2660v3 Xeons and a Radeon Pro WX4100. Audio would not be hardware transcoded. They should be able to handle 3x 4K and 5x 4K streams respectively. I would say plex is like sublime-text: closed source but free, minimal and performant, while jellyfin is like atom: open source and slightly resource intensive. At the same time, use nvidia-smi to verify it is transcoding on the GPU. So, if you have a server that can play 4K, but not transcode picture or sound very well, you'll need a beefy player that can handle the most codecs and do it in direct play. if your source file in 3 mbps bitrate, re-encoding to 20mbps on Try it with hardware transcoding set to vaapi, not quick sync. The transcoding works as expected in this case, which also means it Issues with Jellyfin transcoding on unraid. 265 SDR is available in 10. Jellyfin also shows you the target bitrate. Occassionally, when a session fails to close out gracefully, you can end up with some Transcode cache that Using jellyfin (server) 10. Ideally you probably want to look at hardware offload (ie. To fix this, go into the dashboard for your jellyfin server, go to dlna, profiles (at the top of the screen), scroll down and click on samsung smart tv, click direct play, and add "hevc" along with the other codecs that can be played for whatever container your video was in and then click save (a container is usually the same as the file The other advantage with Jellycon is that you can tell it to transcode certain things, like HDR content if playing on an SDR TV in order to get tonemapping. Thanks for everyone willing to help ;-) When you say Intel GPU do you mean Arc or an iGPU. Avoid Pi4 in your use case. . Media Player: ExoPlayer, Choolse player automatically. If kodi direct plays it then I don't think it does that. The speed of AV1 software encoders are not ready for on the fly transcoding, it'll take some time before catching up libx264 and even libx265. Transcoding your media may be unnecessary because maybe your device/client can handle it. 0 is now available! The main features in this release are. Do you enable Transcoding? Discussion. Then jellyfin goes through checks if the client requesting the file is within the subnet ifnot then it proceeds to transcode based on your Playback>Stream settings. If you do not log out and back in, remote control, SyncPlay, and UI updates break. Use an external player (VLC or even better, MPV) with Jellyfin for Android TV. On the client side i have tried the following. to see the status of all plays you need to go to Dashboard (as admin). Not_a_Candle. Use VLC and "open network" with the above URL. For plex I’ve used the plex app and plex kodi connect for a while also. Resolution is really overrated as far as video quality goes anyway. One alternative could be to use the jellyfin client with an external player (provided you find one that ticks all boxes) but that has also some drawbacks. When I run plex with my other 10 containers, cpu usage is at 5-7% and ram usage is at 1. In my case, using VLC means my previously transcoded 10-bit h264 Jellyfin Media Player 1. You NEED Hardware which supports this. trying to login on either gives me the same “user unauthorized 401” message. First step would be, when installing jellyfin , to select "allocate 1 (2,3,4) GPU to app" . I run them both on one unraid server and share the same media. Grab the URL of the video stream. Jellyfin is very strong as a library manager and also has fairly good options for playback. Myrenic. My IPTV experience has been rocky, but I am also doing nonstandard stuff (custom IPTV sources, custom xmltv generator). I'm also running Komga for my comics and Manga. Under the summary tab, set the format to 'Matroska'. Best bang for buck is to find an old GTX 1050ti 4GB or GTX 1060 6GB. This just enables the ability to transcode a file of any codec into the currently most space-efficient codec and thus get the best bang for your bandwidth buck. Also there is no transcoding on the client side. 265 is feasible but it has not been added to ffmpeg 4. Just change the bitrate in the player, if you force it lower than the file bitrate it'll force a transcode. If your server winds up trying to transcode all five streams of 4k/h265 to 1080p at the same time you may have issues, but this may happen no matter what hardware you use GPU. 4. Jellyfin's hardware settings are extensive, but a bit lacking in documentation. Browsers have very limited support for codecs and containers. is juddering) and the transcode bit rate should be lowered for subsequent segments if not. If I understand you right here, then what you need is HDR Tone-Mapping. Then install Jellyfin and try to use it. 1 then I get direct play (weird). And yes, this would let you play files that cannot be transcoded in realtime using available hardware. I have a newer Pentium CPU in my server that can do everything up to x265 10-bit. I'm running Jellyfin on an Rpi4 which isn't powerful. Set it up to either use the external player as default, if most of the library isn't supported by the native players. It's a shame since I was hoping to leave transcoding on for cases where it's actually necessary for compatibility. Verify it plays and also that the media information is hevc. (6GB) offers better performance. Ah, lol, okay. For transcoding I presume. 4 (Linuxserver image) on Docker, running on a PC with an Intel i7-7500U (HD Graphics 620). I've made sure though for all of my clients to direct play and also keep 1080p versions of my 2160p movies that get selected as the default version. I run into issues trying to play an H265 HEVC file over browsers (FF/Chrome) because they don't support the codec which forces Jellyfin to call FFMpeg and transcode the file down the H264. Jellyfin didn't even have any auto-generated documentation until 10. Jellyfin does this out of the box, you just need to choose the desired quality level on the client side, just like you would to change the quality when watching a YouTube video. DTS-HD transcoding randomly stopped working. Instead, we welcome you to join us at our new forum: https://forum. In the server playback settings there's a setting called "boost audio with downmixing" which might default to 2. Unless you're using more than a couple users and transcoding the audio files, a Raspberry Pi 4b 2GB would be just fine. The client then connects directly to your NAS and plays the file. (H. Jelly pros: hardware transcoding is free. Tap on your account button in the app, then "Client Settings", then change "Video player type" to "External player", then change "External player app" to the supported app of your choice. When I play a file on client, with audio set to 5. No, Emby purposefully broke connectivity with Jellyfin by introducing client side checks that prevent connections to Jellyfin servers. There is an "Auto" setting used by default. But audio transcoding is trivial compared to video, you would not have trouble due to that. However I just got a HDR10 movie, and I noticed that some colors look strange, a bit like watching a 3D movie without the The resulting file has a high Bitrate because it is influenced by the quality setting in the admin interface. ) If you want to have a constant specific Bitrate you can choose the quality in the player. Plex tries to accommodate as many players and hardware as it can. 9, I found that whenever the video is transcoded, if the original audio format was FLAC, it will result in no Arch linux host -> Docker -> Jellyfin. This is how I was able to make things work when using a reverse proxy, otherwise I was unable to get it to transcode to the desired Mbps globally for remote users vs local users. I don't have any any desire to trancode but if I did the jellyfin client would allow that from the same backend. If the client can't play the codec that's direct-playing, no amount of bandwidth is going to help (e. The right question is, when do you need transcoding? If client device is able to play the media as-is, no transcoding is required. And unfortunately AMD is far enough behind all other options to make it a bad choice for a media server. After playing different 4k files and twiddling with settings on server side I come across puzzling configs. on the fly transcoding will never be as good as the source material, and this is why Direct Play is the always preferred. The server GPU is more than fast enough to handle the transcode, so it's a client side problem, maybe somebody familiar with the ATV client can help. Yes. This lasted for multiple months then it is gone again. 0 instead of 1. I’ve also tried quick connect when I put in the 6 digits on the client side it does nothing and on the server side it says device authorized. 13 votes, 10 comments. The welcome thread is available here, and the forum, as well following. For myself at home I now prefer Jellyfin. Pre-transcoding your videos will only get your worse quality files for a lot of time involved. Jellyfin is great if all you want to do is stream your media with no frills, no extras and no third party. I followed SpaceInvaderOne his tutorial on how to set up unraid with the Nvidia drivers to use hardware acceleration. wuast94 · October 22, 2021 · 09:41 Then shut it down by using its icon in the system tray (for Windows). With transcoding disabled, how does Jellyfin handle a client that only supports 1080p direct play and there is a 4k and 1080p file? Question Say my server has transcoding disabled, and a client who can only direct play 1080p tries to play a movie that has two files a 1080p version and 4k version. For instance, Jellyfin server should always try using more efficient formats such as h265 (HEVC) and VP9, then fall back to h264 if a client does not support those more modern formats. I use a i3 version of that CPU family with Arch and Docker and it actually works OK for general trasncoding. On Android TV, you can't choose the desired quality; "Auto" is always used. Pi4 as server is OK when there is no transcoding, it can only transcode with hardware acceleration for 1080p video only. So my Movies Library has a folder setup as: Kodi handles far more natively than the jellyfin client does and native mode bypasses any transcoding (which I don't want) so can handles 5. Jellyfin can play these files with subtitles with very little buffer, and ~30% CPU usage. Android mobile client only allow h265 direct play, but h265 transcoding profiles are not added yet, which should be easy if someone want to impl it. I assume you try watching with a browser atm. At first I was looking at options for syncing watch status across multiple Kodi devices and decided to give Jellyfin a try as one of the simpler sounding solutions. Make subtitle position and scale settings work with SSA and bitmap subtitles. To fix it, you can run the following on your docker host: ****jellyfin | sudo chmod g+rw /dev/dri/card0jellyfin |jellyfin | **** The device /dev/dri/renderD128 does not have group read/write permissions, which might prevent hardware transcode from functioning correctly. In the case a client needs transcoding it only is 1080p to 1080p or lower which allows for about three to four people to transcode - the server starts struggling immsensely with four pople though. Also transcoding only happens on the server if the client doest have bandwith to direct stream or cant handle the media. affordable choice but may not be as suitable for multiple 4K H265. 1 ac3. 1. This is AV1 decode, but H264 encode. You could do it if you used a separate user only for the roku. They add new features before fixing old features. Then one time I hit attempt playback correction and from then on without messing with it, the server would transcode all media sent to the Roku into 5. My current workaround is the android app and screen mirroring, but thats imperfect at best. e. It would more commonly be referred to as "H264 transcoding", since the destination codec is much more important in the transcoding process. ago. Also, we have broken API compat in a few serious ways, so even if you work around their purposeful breaking lots of shit wont work right anymore. 1) it can result in higher quality because a pre-transcode doesn't have to be done at a playable speed letting the encoder find better means of compression and 2) transcoding is expensive electrically, especially if you redo it tons of times (and while I say expensive I'm picturing a few cents a month max per transcode) so only doing it once May 1, 2021 · The client should report to the server whenever it is unable to receive at the current bitrate (i. for multiple devices and users. It would be much easier to help if you provided more information, like what OS you're using, what hardware, what codecs you're trying to transcode, etc. When things are running normally, there should be two entries. Plex does not currently have plans to add AV1 transcoding. Decoding is fine, but they have never really put the effort into quality encoding. Pass through /dev/dri (with devices:, not volumes: ) Add privileged: true. (I don't use Docker Swarm for Jellyfin because you have to pass through /dev/dri as devices) Docker Compose docker-compose -f jellyfin-compose. Often things played remotely involve transcoding. I am currently runner Jellyfin on an RPi 4, on Umbrel OS. You can find that under Dashboard -> Playback. handle the added power/cooling requirements. Ive recently had issue with the Jellyfin app with TV shows where they skip to the end randomly during playback. But, HDR tonemapping on Quicksync can only do HDR10, if you need HLG, you'd have to use VAAPI, which may not work as well. Jellyfin transcodes video to h264, which is about half as bitrate efficient as h265. I am always surprised when I see people having transcoding enabled. Let me know if both are there or if one is missing. FFMPEG is indeed one such converter. For the tuner I tried with 'Allow hardware transcoding' enabled and disabled. Jellyfin didn't recognize hdr last time I tried and I found the user experience way better on Plex than on Emby or Jellyfin, Jellyfin being the worst of the three. Currently it's showing as (hevc (native) -> h264 (h264_vaapi)). Probably because there isn’t enough bandwidth on the remote client to play natively (direct play) or container the file is in is not natively supported. Currently we use the web client to access Jellyfin, however (dependant on show/movie) we have issues with transcoding slowing playback. Plus there's other factors to consider, like burning subtitles, etc. Be it compatibility or I am about to setup a TrueNas Scale NAS and would really want this to be able to hw transcode. BananaRamaBam. I think the best way is to use a client compatible with the video formats. Change all the h264 options to h265. Jellyfin is fully self-hosted. You cannot use plex without creating and logging in to an account on Plex's central servers. I know PGS subtitles are images, not text, but I wouldn't think transcoding would be necessary to display them. Since realtime transcoding prioritizes speed over quality, it's much less bitrate efficient than the original encode. a Nvidia GPU for NVENC etc) if transcoding 4K will be a common occurrence. Like if we say the video is 4k but the client is only 1080 well the client does the 4k to 1080 conversion client side. If you're planning on a lot of simultaneous transcodes, a different device would be more suited. I am currently prototyping the Jellyfin setup to gain the WAF. It also shows what exactly you are playing, resolution, sound, container type, etc. At the end of the day, I prefer sublime-text. g. Lo and behold, when I turn subtitles off, or use external subtitles with the "search" function, Plex ceases to be a CPU hog, and the buffer time matches Your processor has hardware transcoding capabilities that will take most of the transcoding load. There is an info panel within the media player which tells you if you are transcoding. Regarding your caching question, Jellyfin will cache the video until the session ends. I'm using a Pi4b 4GB for my Jellyfin with 4k, HD, and Music. On the server side, you can run it on practically anything. The host is a newish 5700g, MSI B550M, 16GB DDR4 that also hosts my security camera software and home assistant. KabyLakeX (UHD6xx) => All SkyLake have and HEVC (10bit), VP9 (10bit) TigerLakeX (UHD7xx & Xe) => All KabyLake have and AV1. Transcoding is used to play a media file when the video codec is not supported by the device playing back the content. Echoing skribe. 1. I have enabled QSV and everything works as intended. So, if the user starts a movie, it fully transcodes, then they quit out and come back (even a minute later) Jellyfin will have cleared that cache. The client requested mpegts but it's transcoding on the server. As for using the intel GPU, that should work fine, they are quite capable for media. If, on the other hand, client device indicates that it doesn't support the format and/or the resolution of the media as stored, server must transcode media to make it accessible to client. I’ve been running plex for few of years (at least) and Jellyfin for a few months. If it’s the case, you may expect some interruptions on the video, or subtitles not appearing immediately. org. Software > Intel quick sync > Nvidia > AMD. Jellyfin still re-encodes the video. As you can see from the first table, if you use Kodi with either the Jellyfin for Kodi Addon or JellyCon Addon you can pretty much play anything without transcoding. Play a file on the jellyfin web interface that will require transcoding. 🎥 An experimental native video player can now be enabled in the app settings! If you enable fMP4, but do not have hardware acceleration configured on your server, you should disable HEVC encoding in the server Transcoding settings. It's outputting 4k AVC also at a high bitrate (30 is still high), so no surprise that the rpi4 without hardware acceleration cannot play it smoothly. It'd be great if jellyfin had a server side setting to always prefer direct play/stream, never allow transcoding unless required for compatibility. Sleepy-McLovin. At 1080p you can do upwards of a dozen streams. I've heard that using the Kodi app with the Jellyfin add on doesn't have this issue. You can find out more from here. At the same time use the information button in the mobile app's Dashboard screen, that'll tell you the target codec, bitrate, the speed/progress of transcoding and the reason that transcoding started. Jellyfin client works fairly well on android tv platforms. But this has bigger drawbacks in regards to quality. Intel Quick Sync has been setup correctly I think, as it can transcode perfectly to my DLNA client (a "Sony Bravia (2014)" TV according to the DLNA profile selected), when subtitle is set to "Always Off", that is This has the side effect of sadly breaking all existing sessions. If HDR metadata exists in the header or SEI of H. AMD's RX 550 (4GB) is also an. However, if I play the video from my web browser, it's format is incompatible so it has to be transcoded. So a 40Mb h265 would be ~80Mb once transcoded. Plex cons: hardware transcoding is behind a paywall. 265 requires client support) Preserving HDR metadata when transcoding to H. You also need to consider the playback compatibility of the client. Apple TV has native DS Video client Wich IMHO is the best jellyfin alternative, BTW I'm now running jellyfin coz I moved to Roku TVs, and temporarily I'm forced to not stream hevc/4k due jellyfin Roku client still immature, but Plex behavior it's worst as it triggers video transcoding even for subtitles (jellyfin avoid it in h264, only The codec of the source file is irrelevant here - Jellyfin has had support for decoding AV1 files in software and hardware forever. I get transcoding when playing, but if I change audio to 7. Also, the ability to use sideloaded apps such as SmartTube is amazing, it's a YouTube app with Sponsorblock built in, very similar to YouTube Vanced but for Android TV. I spun up jellyfin and I installed Swiftfin in my phone and Apple TV. Software and ease of use is high, however the only hurdle is transcoding issues. Thereby requiring you to disable transcoding temporarily on the server side to force it to direct play. • 1 yr. There are some slight issues but the app is getting major update in a few months that may iron most of the daily nuisances. This will play without transcoding in the web client and the Android app. Some features haven't worked properly for years with no word on if or when a fix will come. 1 native dsf files from my SACD rips and play them 5. For example most 4K media is encoded with h265 and when you transcode to h264 the performance will take a huge hit. Right now, the Android TV app doesn't dynamically detect what codecs your TV supports, instead the codecs that "need transcoding" are hardcoded into the app. Edit: to avoid transcoding, you'll want to convert your media ahead of time using H264 for the video and AAC for the audio. Replace the existing image name with your-name/jellyfin. After much internal discussion amongst the project members and leadership, we have decided to end our subreddit blackout, but leave r/jellyfin read-only, indefinitely. Tone Mapping via Software is insanely slow and therefore not used by Jellyfin, which is why you see wrong colors here. otherwise you can check directly the With both Plex then Emby. the best possible settings is the same settings as your source file if you can find that information from mediainfo. I used to have a bitrate limit for streaming but I removed it. At least I'm assuming "native" means no acceleration. Also, Jellyfin doesn't really have any hand-written API documentation. It just sits on a top shelf in a storage room in the basement with only power and ethernet connected. Plex however, will take between 20 to 30 seconds to begin playing, causing close to 100% CPU usage. transcodes. If the subtitle file is not supported in the client and the subtitle is integrated in the mkv, the server has to extract the subtitle and process it for the client. VPP TM: KabyLakeX (except UHD610), TigerLakeX. Still a new user of Jellybin here, running it on a Synology docker container. The reason it starts transcoding is because of incompatibilities on (most of the time) client (consumer) side. Most of my app is based off Emby's documentation on GitHub and looking at how the Jellyfin web client does it by looking at requests in browser developer tools. Otherwise all the transcoding stuff is done on the client. •. But you'd also need Jellyfin to run custom ffmpeg commands during encoding and I don't know how to pass a custom command to ffmpeg through jellyfin. While these Xeons seem to at least churn out about Especially if you want to use it remotely and/or have remote users. Reply. This setting continued through using the emby app with my jellyfin server on the Roku. Direct Stream Live TV: Enabled and Disabled. Of course, i can use VLC or mpv as external player and it works without transcoding, but the resume function doesn't really work it's resuming a bit at random ^^ Any idea about how to avoid those transcoding (and using the internal player) (specially for the audio)? Anyway, it doesn' t change that jellyfin is great :) Thanks! Open your docker compose file. There's a way to make ffmpeg encode an episode while adding glsl shaders into it. 9 - No audio if video (with FLAC audio) was transcoded and played on Windows Client Help Request On Windows 11 I have been using browser and never had this problem, but when I moved to using the Jellyfin client 1. Yep it seems this is the only current server side way to prevent excessive transcoding. FWIW with Jellyfin for Kodi you can request a transcode on any item from the context menu. Such as Jellyfin Media Player for instance. 3g. 265 video, I think MPV can handle it with proper tone mapping. In the audio tab, I check to make sure the audio track is AAC, and then in the subtitle tab, I delete the subtitle track selections. jellyfin. r/jellyfin. Check the used GPU's condition and ensure your server can. My main client is Jellyfin Media Player 1. 1 for Linux. Audio transcoding has next to no overhead compared to video transcoding. Most of my Blu Ray rips have the audio encoded as DTS HD, which is not supported by Roku, but it wasn't a problem, my pi would just transcode it and it would work fine. So what triggers transcoding? Bandwidth issue, if you are on same LAN usually this won't be a problem; 2nd is client codec support, web player has no HEVC support (unless you pay Microsoft for HEVC . If it transcodes, there is a good reason for it. Your environment and your gear are your choice. 4. - Open the Activity Monitor, and check for "Jellyfin". mv tc cw gd nl rj mi mt ga ie